As life in New York City grows costlier by the day, many residents are reevaluating what it means to call the city home. The once-reasonable trade-off between urban access and affordable housing has tilted sharply, making ownership and even rentals a distant dream for many. Since July 2020, condo prices have risen 16 percent and co-op prices have climbed over 6 percent, according to CityRealty. Meanwhile, rents are averaging $5,194 a month, often surpassing what homeowners elsewhere pay in mortgage installments.

It’s little wonder that families, couples, and solo professionals are casting their gaze beyond the city limits in search of more space, lower costs, and a higher quality of life—without sacrificing access to New York’s job market and cultural core. From the tree-lined avenues of Westchester to coastal communities in Connecticut and ferry-serviced towns in New Jersey, a new wave of suburban migration is reshaping what it means to live “near” New York City. Real estate experts point to several standout commuter suburbs where residents can strike a rare balance between affordability, charm, and convenience.

🗂️ STORY HIGHLIGHTS — READ BOX:

• Rye, NY: Classic Westchester towns with train access, community, and beachside living

• Red Bank & Little Silver, NJ: Ferry to Manhattan, top schools, coastal charm

• Norwalk, CT: Artsy, affordable, and ranked among best for families

• Bronxville, NY: Village feel, short train rides, limited but coveted real estate

• Massapequa Park, NY: Best-ranked in NY, diverse and vibrant community

• Essex County, NJ (Maplewood, etc.): Strong schools, suburban lifestyle for Brooklynites

• Croton-on-Hudson, NY: Affordable with river views and rich local culture

• Riverdale, NYC: Bronx-based suburbia with Metro-North access and greenery

Rye, Harrison, Larchmont & Beyond: Westchester’s Timeless Allure

Westchester County has long been seen as New York City’s backyard—close enough to commute, far enough to breathe. Kirsten Jordan, a seasoned real estate broker with Corcoran, points to towns like Rye, Harrison, Armonk, and Larchmont as top choices for city expats. With train rides to Grand Central averaging 30 to 40 minutes, these towns marry practicality with lifestyle. “You’re getting well-rated public and private schools, tax dollars that actually come back to the community, and that rare feeling of belonging,” she notes. Many families are drawn not just by square footage, but by beach access, golf courses, and parks that make these towns more than just bedrooms for commuters—they’re full, vibrant communities.

Sailing to the City: Red Bank and Little Silver, NJ

The idea of New Jersey commuting usually conjures images of sluggish NJ Transit trains, but there’s another, breezier way. From Atlantic Highlands and Highlands, the Seastreak Ferry glides commuters into Lower Manhattan in just about 30 minutes. Yes, it’s pricier—with a book of 40 tickets costing $720—but it’s fast, clean, and comes with an onboard bar. A short drive inland brings you to Red Bank and Little Silver, towns that blend coastal charm with suburban convenience. Slightly more affordable than the nearby Fair Haven or Rumson, they also shine academically. Little Silver’s Markham Place School ranks among the state’s top middle schools, and specialized high schools nearby consistently rank among the best in New Jersey.

Norwalk, Connecticut: Affordable Seaside Appeal

Tucked into affluent Fairfield County, Norwalk is often overshadowed by its posh neighbors like Greenwich or Darien. But in terms of value and vibe, Norwalk stands tall. With a median home sale price just under $565,000 in 2022, it combines affordability with culture, coastal access, and kid-friendly attractions like the Maritime Aquarium and Stepping Stones Museum. The SoNo (South Norwalk) district buzzes with art galleries and dining options, while events like the annual Oyster Festival ensure there’s never a dull weekend. And the best part? You’re still just an hour away from Grand Central via Metro-North.

Bronxville: A Village with City Roots

Located only 15 miles from Manhattan, Bronxville has quietly become one of the most sought-after commuter towns. Senior VP of Communications at Brown Harris Stevens, Ashley Brennan, has lived there for over a decade. “The express train gets you into Midtown in under 30 minutes,” she explains. Despite being just a square mile in size, the village packs in local shops, cafes, grocers, and several schools, both public and private. The catch? Housing stock is limited, as families tend to plant deep roots here. If you can snag a home, you’re likely to stay until the kids graduate.

Massapequa Park: Long Island’s Hidden Gem

Recently crowned the best place to live in New York by U.S. News & World Report, Massapequa Park on Long Island blends affordability with access. Commuters enjoy a 30-minute ride into the city via the LIRR, while residents praise its tight-knit community and local parks. Affectionately dubbed “Matzo-Pizza Park” for its blended Jewish and Italian heritage, the town boasts walkable streets, family-centric events, and proximity to Jones Beach. With median home values at $627,805, it’s a rare Long Island find offering both value and convenience.

Essex County’s Commuter Cluster: Suburbia with Brooklyn Soul

For many Brooklyn families looking to upgrade space without abandoning culture, Essex County’s cluster of Maplewood, South Orange, Millburn, and Short Hills offers a compelling solution. Broker Svetlana Choi calls this area “New Jersey’s answer to Westchester.” On the Midtown Direct line, the towns are well-connected, and offer strong schools, bustling main streets, and even Broadway-level productions at Millburn’s Paper Mill Playhouse. These towns have a nostalgic, small-town air while still catering to city-minded residents with a taste for style and sophistication.

Croton-on-Hudson: River Views Without the Price Tag

Often overlooked in favor of flashier Westchester names, Croton-on-Hudson is quietly gaining fans—especially among buyers tired of bidding wars. “You can find homes here for nearly half the price of similar properties in places like Bronxville,” says Eli Pasternak of Liberty House Buying Group. The town boasts stunning Hudson River views, a strong school system, and cultural landmarks like Van Cortlandt Manor and the Great Jack O’Lantern Blaze. Express trains to the city take about an hour, making the trade-off in price and space an easy sell.

Riverdale: Suburbia Without Leaving the City

Though technically part of the Bronx, Riverdale feels a world away from the concrete grind of Manhattan. Tree-lined streets, spacious homes, and green spaces like Van Cortlandt Park and Wave Hill make it a suburban oasis inside the city limits. “It’s ideal for people who want more room and quiet without losing quick access to the city,” says Douglas Elliman’s Erin Boisson Aries. Buyers have been showing increased interest in single-family homes here, though the area also offers a healthy mix of co-ops and rentals for those not ready to purchase.

As the financial realities of living in New York City continue to tighten, more residents are discovering that life beyond the boroughs doesn’t have to mean isolation or inconvenience. These commuter towns—each unique in character, offerings, and commute times—are fast becoming the answer to a question many New Yorkers are asking: “Where can I have more, without giving up everything I love about city life?” From ferries to forests, arts to affordability, the suburbs may just hold the keys to New York’s next chapter.

We appreciate you taking the time to read our most recent article! We appreciate your opinions and would be delighted to hear them. We value your opinions as we work hard to make improvements and deliver material that you find interesting.

Post a Comment:

In the space provided for comments below, please share your ideas, opinions, and suggestions. We can better understand your interests thanks to your input, which also guarantees that the material we offer will appeal to you. Get in Direct Contact with Us: Please use our “Contact Us” form if you would like to speak with us or if you have any special questions. We are open to questions, collaborations, and, of course, criticism. To fill out our contact form, click this link.

Stay Connected:

Don’t miss out on future updates and articles.